Silvergate Writedown Casts Doubt on Future of Meta’s Failed Stablecoin Project

Share This Post


Crypto banking group Silvergate Capital additional cooled its stablecoin ambitions final week, slashing the worth of property that it bought from a defunct Fb crypto mission.

Silvergate disclosed that it took a $196 million impairment cost throughout its closing fiscal quarter of final yr, writing down the worth of mental property and expertise that it acquired from Diem Group early final yr.

The revised determine represents a 98% loss in comparison with the $200 million it paid for the property. Silvergate had deliberate to launch a stablecoin utilizing the property final yr, saying plans to take action in its third fiscal quarter of 2021. 

The corporate stated it deliberate to combine the property it received from Diem into its Silvergate Alternate Community (SEN), an around-the-clock system for transferring cash utilized by its institutional shoppers. Silvergate stated final week, nevertheless, that the stablecoin’s launch is firmly on maintain.

“Given the numerous modifications within the digital asset business panorama, this cost displays the Firm’s perception that the launch of a blockchain-based cost answer by Silvergate is now not imminent,” the corporate reported.

In a enterprise replace convention name, Silvergate CEO Alan Lane stated that the impairment cost was as a result of it might be tough to deliver a stablecoin to market “anytime quickly,” citing the present crypto atmosphere.

Michael Perito, managing associate at funding financial institution KBW, described the impairment cost Silvergate took on its Diem property as a part of the everyday accounting course of firms soak up reviewing intangible property.

“You want to have the ability to have an inexpensive estimate as to when one thing may flip tangible, and I feel the regulatory backdrop within the crypto world proper now could be simply actually unsure,” he informed Decrypt. “Close to time period, Silvergate buyers most likely should not get their hopes up {that a} stablecoin mission goes to launch.” 

The corporate additionally reported a 68% drawdown on its deposits throughout its closing fiscal quarter of final yr, in addition to a $718 million loss on debt liquidated to satisfy the flurry of withdrawals. Moreover, the financial institution disclosed it might minimize its headcount by 40%.

Following the replace, Silvergate’s inventory worth plummeted. It closed out the buying and selling day 43% decrease than the day earlier than at $12.57 per share. 

Lane had beforehand pumped the brakes on Silvergate’s stablecoin launch final October, advising it appeared unlikely to occur throughout the yr. 

“We’re actually upset that it appears to be like like we’re going to miss our aim of launching it [the stablecoin] this yr,” Lane stated. “The expertise that we acquired earlier this yr was able to go after we acquired it.”

Following his feedback, The financial institution’s inventory worth slumped 23% within the following buying and selling day to $54.71, pulled down partly by poor earnings performance. Silvergate reported earnings-per-share of $1.28 for the quarter in comparison with analyst expectations of $1.46.

Fb had supposed to launch Diem, initially introduced as Libra in 2019, as a stablecoin that was tied to a basket of worldwide currencies. As an alternative of being pegged to the greenback’s worth like different stablecoins like Tether or Circle’s USD coin, the token may’ve primarily grow to be its personal international forex.

However Libra confronted scrutiny from regulators within the U.S. and Europe. Fb Chief Government Mark Zuckerberg stated his firm would abandon the project if regulators didn’t approve of it earlier than the U.S. Home Monetary Providers Committee in October of 2019.  

Whereas Silvergate didn’t put ahead a timeline for launching its stablecoin throughout its current enterprise replace, Lane stated the corporate was not abandoning Diem, in contrast to Fb finally did after companions resembling Mastercard, Visa, and eBay pulled out.

“There are nonetheless folks on the mission,” Lane stated. “As we sit right here at this time, we’ll clearly need to proceed to guage.”

A spokesperson for Silvergate informed Decrypt the corporate wouldn’t remark about Diem past data printed final week.

Despite the fact that the corporate’s mission stays in limbo, JP Morgan analysts highlighted the stablecoin’s potential to bolster long-term earnings for Silvergate in a current analysis be aware. 

“Whereas we’re not stunned that the corporate is delaying the launch of a stablecoin given a must handle expense ranges down, this stays an space the place we stay very bullish,” it acknowledged.

Keep on high of crypto information, get day by day updates in your inbox.

Related Posts